Korean registry study links asystole-to-PEA conversion during CPR to better neurologic outcomes
Persistent PEA carried the highest weighted chance of a good neurologic outcome, and persistent asystole the lowest, in adults with initial nonshockable rhythms.
Key takeaways
- A Critical Care Medicine study indexed November 12, 2026 analyzed adult out-of-hospital cardiac arrests with initial nonshockable rhythms in South Korea's nationwide registry from 2016 through 2021.
- Patients were grouped by rhythm change during CPR: asystole-to-asystole, asystole-to-PEA, PEA-to-asystole, and PEA-to-PEA.
- Weighted risk of good neurologic outcome at discharge was 0.101% for persistent asystole, 0.231% for asystole-to-PEA, 0.384% for PEA-to-asystole, and 0.874% for persistent PEA.
- Compared with persistent asystole, the odds of a good outcome were 2.28 times higher after asystole-to-PEA conversion and 8.70 times higher with persistent PEA.
- The abstract does not report the total number of patients, how transitions were timed, or any US data.
A nationwide registry study published in Critical Care Medicine and indexed on PubMed on November 12, 2026 reports that the direction of rhythm change during CPR was associated with neurologic outcome in adults whose out-of-hospital cardiac arrest began in a nonshockable rhythm [1]. The authors, led by Dongju Kim with Won Young Kim as the final listed author, drew on the Nationwide OHCA Registry of South Korea, which is managed by the Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency [2].
The study sorted patients into four groups by what happened to their rhythm during resuscitation: asystole that stayed asystole, asystole that converted to pulseless electrical activity (PEA), PEA that deteriorated to asystole, and PEA that persisted [1]. Conversion from asystole to PEA was associated with a better neurologic outcome than asystole that never changed, according to the abstract [1].
The findings are observational and come from one country's registry. The authors describe the value of the work as prognostic context rather than a treatment finding, writing that "Recognizing these patterns may provide prognostic context beyond a single rhythm assessment" [2].
What the records show
The study design is described as a nationwide population-based observational study with no intervention [1]. It included consecutive adult patients, defined as 18 years or older, with nonshockable rhythms from January 1, 2016 through December 31, 2021 [2].
The primary outcome was good neurologic outcome at hospital discharge, defined as a Cerebral Performance Category score of 1-2 [1]. The authors used inverse probability of treatment weighting, a statistical method, to adjust for measured confounding [2].
In the primary weighted model, the risk of a good neurologic outcome in each group was as follows [1]:
| Rhythm pattern during CPR | Weighted risk of good neurologic outcome |
|---|---|
| Asystole to asystole (A-A) | 0.101% |
| Asystole to PEA (A-P) | 0.231% |
| PEA to asystole (P-A) | 0.384% |
| PEA to PEA (P-P) | 0.874% |
Measured against persistent asystole, the odds ratio for a good outcome was 2.28 for asystole-to-PEA (95% CI, 1.78-2.93), 3.80 for PEA-to-asystole (95% CI, 3.01-4.80), and 8.70 for persistent PEA (95% CI, 6.98-10.83) [2]. The corresponding risk differences were 0.130, 0.283, and 0.773 percentage points [1].
The authors also compared the two transition groups directly. PEA that deteriorated to asystole still carried higher odds of a good outcome than asystole that converted to PEA, with an odds ratio of 1.66 (95% CI, 1.39-1.99) and a risk difference of 0.153 percentage points [2].
The abstract summarizes the result this way: "Asystole conversion to PEA during CPR was associated with a better neurologic outcome than persistent asystole" [1]. It adds that a shift from PEA to asystole was associated with lower odds of a good outcome than persistent PEA, yet still a better outcome than the asystole-to-PEA group [2].
Why it matters for EMS
Nonshockable rhythms make up the cases where field crews have the least to work with, and a single rhythm check gives one snapshot. This study treats the sequence of rhythm checks during CPR as information in itself [1]. The registry data suggest that the starting rhythm carried more weight than the direction of change: both PEA groups outperformed both asystole groups in the weighted analysis [2].
The absolute numbers are small across every group. Even the best-performing pattern, persistent PEA, had a weighted good-outcome risk under one percent, and persistent asystole was near one in a thousand [1]. The authors frame the findings as prognostic context, not as a basis for changing resuscitation steps [2]. EMS clinicians follow local protocols and medical direction.
What the records do not tell us
- The abstract does not report the total number of patients analyzed or the size of each of the four groups [1].
- It does not say how or when rhythm transitions were timed during CPR, how many rhythm checks were counted, or how patients who later developed a shockable rhythm were handled [2].
- It reports neurologic outcome at discharge only. Survival to discharge, return of spontaneous circulation, and longer-term outcomes are not given in the abstract [1].
- The data come from South Korea's national registry. The records contain no US data and do not address whether the patterns would hold in other EMS systems [2].
- The design is observational with weighting for measured confounders. The abstract does not describe unmeasured confounding or report sensitivity analyses [1].
- The records do not say whether the full paper is open access, and neither source includes a publication volume or issue [2].
What to watch
The records list a DOI for the article in Critical Care Medicine but do not state a date for the full print issue or any planned follow-up analysis [2]. Neither source mentions commentary, an editorial, or a planned validation in another registry.
Questions readers ask
Does asystole converting to PEA during CPR improve outcomes?
In a South Korean nationwide registry study published in Critical Care Medicine, asystole that converted to PEA during CPR was associated with a better neurologic outcome at discharge than asystole that persisted. The weighted risk of a good outcome was 0.231% versus 0.101%, with an odds ratio of 2.28. The study is observational and does not show cause.
What were the four rhythm transition groups in the study?
Patients were grouped as asystole-to-asystole, asystole-to-PEA, PEA-to-asystole, and PEA-to-PEA based on rhythm changes during CPR. Weighted risks of good neurologic outcome were 0.101%, 0.231%, 0.384%, and 0.874% respectively.
Where did the data for the nonshockable rhythm transition study come from?
The data came from the Nationwide OHCA Registry of South Korea, managed by the Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency. It covered consecutive adults aged 18 or older with nonshockable rhythms from January 1, 2016 to December 31, 2021.
Is PEA deteriorating to asystole worse than asystole converting to PEA?
Not in this study. PEA-to-asystole had higher odds of a good neurologic outcome than asystole-to-PEA, with an odds ratio of 1.66 and a risk difference of 0.153 percentage points. Persistent PEA had the highest weighted risk of a good outcome at 0.874%.
Sources
- PubMed record: Neurological Outcomes of Rhythm Transitions in Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest With Initial Nonshockable Rhythms (Critical Care Medicine) (2026-11-12). pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/43018417/
- Critical Care Medicine article via DOI: Neurological Outcomes of Rhythm Transitions in Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest With Initial Nonshockable Rhythms — doi.org. doi.org/10.1097/CCM.0000000000007449
This is news, not medical advice. EMS clinicians: follow your local protocols and medical direction.


