mepa8 Get alerts

Belgian study compares paramedic-only and physician-led prehospital teams across 2,325 calls

Cardiac arrest and seizure care looked alike between the two systems, but physician-led crews did more ECGs for chest pain and intubated more respiratory patients.

Mepa8 headline card: Belgian study compares paramedic-only and physician-led prehospital teams across 2,325 calls

Key takeaways

  • A retrospective Belgian study analysed 2,325 prehospital interventions: 1,377 by paramedical intervention teams (PIT) and 948 by physician-led SMUR units.
  • The authors found cardiac arrest and seizure management comparable between the two systems, and no difference in response times.
  • Physician-led SMUR teams performed more electrocardiograms for chest pain and more intubations for acute respiratory conditions.
  • The authors call for prospective studies before concluding the two systems perform comparably.
  • For crews: the published abstract does not report patient outcomes, study dates or which Belgian region the data came from.

A retrospective study comparing paramedic-only ambulance teams with physician-led units in Belgium found no difference in response times and similar handling of cardiac arrest and seizures, according to an abstract indexed in PubMed on November 16, 2026. The paper appears in the Revue medicale de Liege. [1]

The authors reviewed 2,325 prehospital interventions. Of those, 1,377 were handled by paramedical intervention teams, known as PIT, and 948 by mobile emergency and resuscitation units, known as SMUR, which the title describes as physician-led. [1]

The research team was listed as Moury J, Vandevelde V, Soetewey A, Michaux I, Bulpa P and Thys F. The abstract was published in French with an English version. [1]

What the records show

According to the abstract, Belgium's emergency medical system coordinates both kinds of teams. The authors framed the work around rising demand, writing that wider use of PIT crews might ease the load on SMUR units, while noting that comparative data have been scarce. [1]

The study covered calls for cardiac arrest, trauma, seizures, chest pain and acute respiratory disorders. Researchers looked at patient characteristics, response times and management strategies. [1]

The reported findings, by condition:

  • Cardiac arrest: management was comparable between the two systems. [1]
  • Seizures: management was also comparable. [1]
  • Trauma: both the patients and the treatments they received differed between PIT and SMUR, the authors reported. The abstract does not say how. [1]
  • Chest pain: SMUR teams performed more electrocardiograms. [1]
  • Acute respiratory conditions: the English abstract states that "PIT teams more frequently administered oxygen therapy and aerosol treatment," while SMUR teams intubated more often. [1]
  • Response times: no difference was observed. [1]

The two language versions of the abstract are not identical on oxygen. The English text says PIT crews gave oxygen more frequently. The French text describes PIT oxygen use as different, rather than greater, while agreeing that PIT crews used more aerosols and SMUR crews intubated more. [1]

In their conclusion, the authors wrote that "PIT appears to be a useful alternative when SMUR is unavailable." [1]

Why it matters for EMS

The study addresses a staffing question many systems face: what changes when a call gets a paramedic crew instead of a physician-led unit. In this data set, the clearest differences fell on specific interventions. Physician-led crews did more ECGs on chest pain patients and more airway intubations on respiratory patients. Paramedic crews leaned more on aerosol treatments. [1]

For cardiac arrest and seizures, two high-acuity call types, the authors found care to be comparable. They also found no gap in how fast each team reached the patient. [1]

The authors present PIT crews as a way to relieve pressure on SMUR units as demand grows, at least when a physician-led team is not available. [1]

What the records do not tell us

The abstract leaves several questions open:

  • It does not report patient outcomes such as survival, hospital admission or complications. The comparison is of care delivered, not results.
  • It does not give the study period, the region or the number of services involved.
  • It does not give the size of the differences, such as ECG or intubation rates for each team, or any statistical measures.
  • It does not explain how the trauma populations and treatments differed.
  • It does not say how calls were assigned to PIT or SMUR, so differences in patient mix may reflect dispatch decisions rather than team performance.
  • No DOI was listed in the PubMed record, and the full text was not part of the records reviewed.

Because the design is retrospective, the authors themselves limit their conclusion, writing that "prospective studies are needed before confirming comparable performance between the two systems." [1]

What to watch

The authors call for prospective studies before any conclusion that paramedic teams match physician-led units. The record does not name a planned study or timeline. [1]

Questions readers ask

What is the difference between PIT and SMUR in Belgium?

According to the study abstract, Belgium's emergency medical system coordinates mobile emergency and resuscitation units (SMUR), described in the title as physician-led, and paramedical intervention teams (PIT).

Do paramedic teams respond as fast as physician-led teams in Belgium?

In this retrospective study of 2,325 interventions, the authors observed no difference in response times between PIT and SMUR teams.

How did paramedic and physician teams differ in treating breathing problems?

The English abstract says PIT teams more often gave oxygen and aerosol treatments, while SMUR teams more often intubated. The French abstract describes PIT oxygen use as different rather than more frequent.

Did the Belgian study show paramedic teams are equivalent to physician teams?

No. The authors called PIT a useful alternative when SMUR is unavailable but wrote that prospective studies are needed before confirming comparable performance.

Sources

  1. Moury J, et al. Comparison of prehospital management of selected emergencies between a paramedical team and a physician-led team: a retrospective study in Belgium. Revue medicale de Liege (PubMed) (2026-11-16). pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/43036968/
How this story was made Drafted by Mepa8's AI newsroom from the 1 record listed above and nothing else. Before publication a verification program confirmed that every number and quotation in the story appears in those records, that no passage was copied from them, and that every cited link opens. Editor: Ryan Bolden, EMS professional, who reviews published stories and handles corrections. Medical review pending. How we use AI · Report an error

This is news, not medical advice. EMS clinicians: follow your local protocols and medical direction.

Free alerts

Know about the next recall or outbreak the day it is posted.

One email when a story touches EMS equipment, medications or public health. Plus the free 6am briefing if you want it.

Send me